Reincarnated as a Sword Season 2
Episode 8

by Christopher Farris,

How would you rate episode 8 of
Reincarnated as a Sword (TV 2) ?
Community score: 3.5

raas2081
Ah, there's the plot being paid off after the past pair of episodes played things down. This is ostensibly the "Seedrun Arc," so it stood to reason that Fran and friends would make it to Seedrun eventually. What works about it is how seamlessly the idle elements of the storytelling flow into the much more plot-prominent parts now that things have really kicked off. I mean, mostly; Reincarnated as a Sword is still wont to some dalliances, but even that caveat is much more deal-with-able by my usual annoyed standards.

The sharper storytelling in the sword show is apparent just as it kicks off this week with Fran's fight with the pirates. The "twist" is that they're actually just fishers who have fallen on hard times, and the writing is keen enough to convey that cleanly: Teacher delays the info at first for dramatic effect, then it gets briskly relayed after the fact rather than needing to linger on the stat sheets he checked to learn about it. It's smart—the kind of engaging, economical choice that I've praised when this season makes it (and complained when it doesn't).

Similarly, a lot of clarifying details get conversationally revealed as Fran and Teacher's would-be ferry trip turns into an inter-kingdom diplomatic incident. It's powered by how everything this arc necessarily leads to and from this Seedrun place. The aforementioned fishing-pirates are struggling under the taxes of the kingdom's new ruler, and his representative shows up in the form of Dwight, the latest in Reincarnated as a Sword's efforts at making the least-subtly designed villains in fiction.

This is a show about a sword that cuts straight to the point, and that pointed lack of subtlety can make me forget that Reincarnated as a Sword usually, not always, but usually, having stronger writing than the median isekai is another point that sets it apart from that crowd. Dwight's seemingly a bastard just for bastard's sake, striving to accuse the crew of being criminals and taking them into custody against all evidence, never mind that he stands to gain nothing from these struggles. Teacher notes that this is, of course, the point: Dwight wants these people, specifically the royal twins, as captives no matter what. It works in letting the show get to have its plainly villainous cake and eat it too with a side of solid story structure. It even sets up a secondary antagonist with his accompanying master swordsman rocking the rad enemy epithet of "Valuza the Black Fang." He also kills one of the cool-looking royal guards to show off, which will turn out to be a recurring trick for this show to build this guy up. It's efficient writing, I swear!

In the name of efficiency, I'm fine with this being a way to get Teacher, Fran, and the others into prison so that they can then be broken out of prison by new characters and members of the royal resistance in Seedrun. And I'm not just coming out in favor of that because the first representative, Miriam, is a tanned, short-haired, badass warrior princess. I can drag this show when I want to, but it will still drag me right back. Case in point: there's a lot of transitional transit after the rescue to lead Teacher and Fran to the other resisting princess of Seedrun and finally get caught up on what all the plot is happening here.

Some of the story of Seedrun had been properly seeded leading up to this, namely the point about sponsoring slave traders, the relationship the twins' own kingdom has that makes them a valuable bargaining chip, and the Godsword they're connected to that piqued Teacher's interest. But now, this could be the part where I gripe about how the exposition explaining all this together after all this time…takes up a good chunk of time, complete with Fran doing her standby falling-asleep gag to drive it home. But honestly, I'm not nearly as bothered by it in this instance as I was other times. It helps that this isn't just out-of-nowhere exposition earlier—it's paying off points that audiences got prior and might even have been taking notes on. And placed as it is, it effectively comes off as a cutscene between missions. I can kind of respect it that way, playing what sounds like a serial-numbers-filed-off version of the "Attack Team" party-assembling music from Final Fantasy Tactics in the background.

Maybe I just get some catharsis about characters discussing how they need to overthrow their dipshit mad king who's cut social services and funneled all the tax dollars into the military. At first I thought the use of the phrase "fake news" in the subtitle script for this episode felt a little out of place, but maybe it was purposeful after all.

It's all a shift I knew this arc was going to need to make sooner or later, and I'm genuinely impressed with how smoothly it makes it. Last week I talked about the undersold element of Fran's friendship with the twins, but at least in this episode, her resolve to rescue them because they're friends does feel genuine, and creates a heartening throughline for that character arc. I also appreciate the continuation of the running gag of Fran not knowing how to properly genuflect to royalty. And as for more macabre running gags, there's this episode's use of another royal guard named Yorth. Yorth pops up in the last couple of minutes to help out the leads, provides an amusing little detail that he kind of sucks at his job, then gets himself killed by that Valuza guy for his trouble. I told you the writing knew what it was doing! It's wild, because the simple act of giving this minuscule side character the barest of defining features before he gets killed means the pathos lands and Valuza's villainy is sold more effectively. That's the quality of Reincarnated as a Sword on display this week: just adding the little touches here and there to make sure its otherwise standardized story structure is held together much more tightly.

Rating: Reincarnated as a Sword Season 2 is currently streaming on HIDIVE.

While you were partying, Chris studied the blade, which is why he's here to talk about swords for another season. See him saying s-words sometimes on his socials.


The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the views of Anime News Network, its employees, owners, or sponsors.

discuss this in the forum (12 posts) |
bookmark/share with: short url

back to Reincarnated as a Sword Season 2
Episode Review homepage / archives