Review

by Richard Eisenbeis,

Witch on the Holy Night Anime Film Review

Synopsis:
Witch on the Holy Night Anime Film Review
Aoko Aozaki has a busy life to say the least. By day, she's her high school's student council president. By night, she's expected to protect the city from magical threats. And sometime in between she's supposed to train in magecraft while also living the life of a normal young woman. But when new transfer student Soujyuro Sizuki witnesses her using magecraft, things get even more hectic in her life—especially since she's now expected to kill him to protect the secret that magic exists.
Review:

In the year 1996, Japanese college student Kinoko Nasu finished writing a 400-page book. Less than five copies were ever printed and every publisher who looked at it turned it down. Nasu gave up on the story and moved on. Yet, the world created in this failed novel—along with several of its characters—would find a home in the imaginations of millions across the globe over the coming decades thanks to the success of Nasu's subsequent works. Or to put it another way, without Witch on the Holy Night, there never would have been Tsukihime, Garden of Sinners, or Fate/stay night—or anything related that came after.

All this makes Witch on the Holy Night an important film on a metatextual level for Fate fans. After all, to truly understand where things have gone, you have to know how they began—especially when it comes to the magical system and society that permeates those works.

Unsurprisingly, Witch on the Holy Night has many of the hallmarks seen in Nasu's more famous works. It's set in a small city with both rolling hills and a major river—with the local high school serving as a reoccurring setting. Though rather than being set in the 90s, it takes place in the 80s—presenting a nostalgic world without cellphones or the internet.

Aoko herself is the best part of the film. She is a walking contradiction. She is a person saddled with tons of responsibility and wants none of it. However, because she has accepted the responsibility, she wants to do the job right—regardless of whether it's mundane school admin work or fighting magical threats. She absolutely loathes anyone who makes her job harder or adds to her responsibilities in any way. She's the type who will complain constantly under her breath while appearing stoic in front of others—though she doesn't always succeed in this.

This all stems from her personal moral code. She knows that mages are suppose to be completely self-centered—to do anything to attain their goals without letting pesky things like morals get in the way. However, if Aoko is one thing, it's true to herself. She knows the difference between right and wrong and once she makes a promise (and thus takes on a responsibility), she'll follow it through to the end—even if it means putting herself in harms way. This, of course, is the cause of most of her problems in this film.

Beyond Aoko, the film follows two other characters. One is Alice, the witch tasked with training Aoko to think and act like a mage. They live together and share an almost sisterly friendship—sharing the same goal but also snipping at each other over tiny, petty grievances.

The other main character, the aforementioned Soujyuro, is what ultimately puts the two women at odds with one another. Soujyuro is a boy from a place so rural and remote that things like multi-story buildings or schools are completely new to him. He's a fish out of water, wary of the strange world he's found himself in. However, his defining quality is that he lets his heart guide him once the danger starts.

Together, he and Aoko make an entertaining pair. While he sees Aoko as a helpful, kind person, she hates him since he just keeps adding more things that she's expected to handle. Much of the film's comedy comes from interactions between these two as Aoko is forced to break character in the face of his staggering ignorance of the world.

The film itself looks fantastic—staggeringly so. ufotable takes all it has learned over the years doing both the Fate anime and Demon Slayer to make something constantly detailed, fluid, and dynamic. The use of color is wonderful and the surreality of certain locations is something to behold. That said, the film does sometimes go a bit over-the-top with its visuals. The camera has the bad habit of flying around for an unnecessary amount of time to do extended, complicated establishing shots just because it can.

As for the soundtrack, it's likewise amazing, with both background and insert songs that will stick in your mind even after the film is done.

If the film has one weak point, it's how it ends. I, along with many who have played the visual novel adaptation, wondered how it would be possible to get the entirety of the story into a single, two-hour film. Simply put, it can't—and it doesn't even try. While this film was never advertised as part of a multi-film series, it most certainly is one.

Thus, the film ends in the middle of the story. But the real issue is that it doesn't end at the logical conclusion point after the big action climax and its resolution. Instead, it reaches that point and goes on for an additional 10 minutes, pulling our heroes into the middle of a second major battle before abruptly cutting once the hidden villain is revealed (though only to us, not to Aoko). It's a cliffhanger that will get hardcore fans excited but one that would have worked just as well as a character reveal without the additional, post-climax battle.

In the end, Witch on the Holy Night is a fantastic watch for anyone deep into Fate lore and one that will also work as an easy to understand introduction to the world of mages that populate Nasu's shared world. Aoko is a great character who steals every scene she's in—and her interactions with the two other leads are never anything less than entertaining. If it weren't for the abruptness of the ending, I'd rate this film even higher, but as things stand, I'd still recommend this to any anime fan for the eye candy alone.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the views of Anime News Network, its employees, owners, or sponsors.
Grade:
Overall : B
Story : B-
Animation : A
Art : A+
Music : B

+ Great characters and amazing animation. Fans of Fate will love the deep lore.
− Sometimes gets so lost in its own visuals it forgets it's supposed to be telling a story. Ends abruptly when it doesn't need to.

discuss this in the forum (1 post) |
bookmark/share with: short url

this article has been modified since it was originally posted; see change history

Add this anime to
Production Info:
Chief Director: Hikaru Kondo
Director: Masaru Takeuchi
Script: Hikaru Kondo
Storyboard:
Hikaru Kondo
Takahiro Miura
Keigo Takenaka
Masaru Takeuchi
Kei Tsunematsu
Unit Director:
Seiji Harada
Hideki Hosokawa
Ken Nakazawa
Masato Saitō
Tetsuto Satō
Shinya Shimomura
Takashi Suhara
Keigo Takenaka
Masaru Takeuchi
Kei Tsunematsu
Akihiko Uda
Music: Hideyuki Fukasawa
Original creator: Kinoko Nasu
Original Character Design: Hirokazu Koyama
Character Design: Moe Tsuzuki
Art Director: Koji Eto
Chief Animation Director: Masato Nagamori
Animation Director:
Mihoko Adachihara
Kōji Akiyama
Mika Bandō
Noriko Fujimoto
Shōgo Fujiwara
Kana Ishigo
Yuri Katō
Yui Kobayashi
Masaharu Koyama
Madoka Kumagai
Kaori Matsushima
Takayuki Mogi
Masato Nagamori
Kumiko Nakashiki
Shintarou Nomura
Mieko Ogata
Kayo Onizawa
Yukiko Saijō
Kai Saitō
Wakako Shigemoto
Yūsuke Shingū
Tomonori Sudō
Yukari Takeuchi
Atsushi Tanaka
Aya Tanaka
Moe Tsuzuki
Toko Uchimura
Yaeko Watanabe
3D Director: Naoki Satō
Sound Director: Hikaru Kondo
Director of Photography: Yuichi Terao
Producer:
Hikaru Kondo
Yūma Takahashi

Full encyclopedia details about
Witch on the Holy Night (movie)

Review homepage / archives