This Week in Anime
Kaiju King

by Sylvia Jones & Jairus Taylor,

Godzilla contains multitudes, and we're not just talking about the people he eats.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by the participants in this chat log are not the views of Anime News Network.
Spoiler Warning for discussion of the series ahead.

Netflix streams Godzilla Minus One, Godzilla Singular Point, and Godzilla Planet of Monsters.
HBO Max streams Godzilla (1954) and Shin Godzilla.

@Jetzero Infinity @BWProwl @LucasDeRuyter @vestenet


Sylvia
Hey, Jairus! Just want to say I'm happy to finally get to do a column with you! Here's to many more to come. And since it's only your second "This Week in Anime" ever, I thought we could ease you into the swing of things with a nice, easy, and small topic we can cover quickly and comprehensively:
sylvia01
Godzilla.
Jairus
Glad to be here with you! Spooky season might be over, but Big G monster fever is eternal, so there's always time to talk about the big guy.
goji-25.png
I am not the most knowledgeable person about Godzilla and will mostly just smile and nod if you try to explain what a Mothra or Jet Jaguar is. Still, it's always been fascinating to see just how much his shadow has continued to loom over the broader media landscape.
Indeed! I would also hardly consider myself a Godzilla Guru, but he's a difficult figure to lose sight of. Everyone knows who Godzilla is, even if it's just through osmosis. Plus, this is an apt time for us to highlight this big angry radioactive lizard, what with Godzilla Minus Zero smashing records this past weekend.

I have yet to catch a showing myself as of the time of writing, but I'm planning to see the big guy in IMAX before he saunters off those screens here. I want him to loom as large as possible, after all.

Same here, although, even if you can't see him in theatres just yet, part of what's helped to make the big guy so culturally relevant is the variety of media he's managed to stomp his way through over the decades. He's been in everything from comics to cartoons and video games. If you can put a giant kaiju dinosaur in it somehow, odds are Godzilla will be in there somewhere.
godzilla-stomp.png
This even includes children's picture books, which might seem like a strange place to put a big scary dino, but hey, you gotta reach them while they're young.
Why not?? This is a fun example our editor Rebecca let us know about, and it's exactly what it looks like: Godzilla using his big steppers to ruin a bunch of classic fairy tales. Officially sanctioned by TOHO and everything!

That is one of the really fun and interesting qualities of Godzilla. That he can be both a gigantic monster/metaphor as well as a universally beloved pop culture figure. Godzilla is both an avatar of wanton destruction and a big blorbo whom I buy merchandise of to gift to my Godzilla-obsessed friends. He contains multitudes, and I'm not just talking about the people he eats.

Indeed. Godzilla stories can come in a variety of flavors. Sometimes you'll get ones like Shin Godzilla that serve as an allegory for all the hand-wringing of Japanese bureaucracy, and many a time you'll get big vehicles of spectacle like the recent run of Legendary films, which mainly just seem like an excuse to crash a bunch of giant monster figurines together and see what happens.
goji-vs-kong.png
Take note: this is an endorsement, not a complaint. I, too, enjoy the delicate art of watching giant monsters pummel each other for 90 minutes.
There are many worse reasons to hit the movies. And honestly, now that the dust is settling on the 2010s' cinematic universe obsession, Legendary's "Monsterverse" has ended up being one of the better examples, if you ask me. 2014's Godzilla was a solid Hollywood blockbuster. I actually thought King of the Monsters was a lot of fun. And I just found out that next year's entry is going to be titled Godzilla x Kong: Supernova, which might be the best film name of all time.
sylvia02
I know these American 'Zillas don't tend to be as highly regarded as their Japanese counterparts, especially in our weeb-saturated circles, but they nevertheless have their defenders—many of them! And I think that's cool that they can go toe-to-toe with the "original" in some ways.
For sure! Of course, considering Godzilla's origins as a post-WWII allegory about the horrors of war and nuclear weapons, there is something poetic about the most critically acclaimed Godzilla film in recent memory being one that takes our favorite kaiju back to his roots.
minus-one-poster.png
I went back through this film in preparation for today's discussion, and for checking out its currently trending sequel, and let me tell ya, this one still has some real sauce.
Right? It occurred to me as we were planning this column that we never really covered Minus One on TWIA back when it came out (mostly because it's hard to screenshot a movie theater screen). And since many people, including the two of us, have revisited it recently, I think it's worth delving a little deeper into its contents.
sylvia03
Incidentally, I used this opportunity to watch the "minus color" version for extra retro vibes. It works pretty well! And I think it makes the special effects look and feel even more impressive, under this veneer of an "older" film.
Unfortunately, I rewatched this via Netflix, so I've only ever seen this film in color, but the look of it is still impressive either way. In particular, one element of the film that immediately stands out visually is how much it doesn't shy away from showing just how devastating the aftermath of the air raids was, and the levels of extreme poverty Japanese civilians were left in.
goji-7.png
goji-8.png
A lot of the impact of that aftermath can also be felt in the film's protagonist, Shikishima, who is constantly going through it.
goji-3.png
He is the movie's Little Beepo, and his misery is increasing constantly. And yes, the narrative's extremely direct tackling of Japan's immediate post-war era is what gives Minus One a lot of its flavor. In the West, we tend to forget that Tokyo was firebombed basically to hell, which was not that far removed from the destructiveness of the atomic bombings. Here, though, the firebombed ruins of Tokyo show up well before Godzilla wreaks any metropolitan havoc. And of course, Shikishima's shame at being a "failed" kamikaze pilot hangs over his head and his interactions with the other characters throughout the film.
sylvia05
In both cases—the background ruins and the foreground anger/depression—they act as mirrors for the pain many Japanese citizens were feeling after World War II.
Yeah, even as the characters try to rebuild their lives, the impact of the war is always inescapable. We even see this when it comes to employment, as the only kind of work Shikishima can find to help support his newfound family involves the extremely risky venture of mine sweeping.
goji-9.png
goji-10.png
goji-11.png
goji-12.png
That desperation also allows us to see a variety of perspectives about the state of the country when Shikishima meets his new crewmates, one of whom very much buys into the propaganda that going to war is something to be celebrated.
goji-13.png
goji-14.png
The war is very much "the monster" that continues to trample on people's lives well past its end date. Which goes part and parcel with Godzilla's common thematic purpose as a consequence of the war, nurtured on radiation and ready to attack the species responsible for it. And like many of the more "serious" takes on Godzilla, Minus One keeps an acerbic sense of humor about this. Godzilla takes literal bites out of warships. Fragile international relations get in the way of an effective response. And the people on the ground find their bravado quickly humbled by Godzilla's awful spectacle.
sylvia06
sylvia07
sylvia08
sylvia09
There's certainly a lot of awful spectacle to be had here, though the beating heart of this film ultimately lies in Shikishima's character arc. The film opens with him becoming the lone survivor of a Godzilla attack, which further feeds into his guilt about failing to do his "duty" as a Kamikaze pilot. Even as he builds a new life with another survivor named Noriko and a war orphan that they agreed to look after, he can never allow himself to feel as though he deserves to be alive, and it's absolutely devastating to watch.
goji-19.png
goji-20.png
goji-21.png
goji-22.png
I know that a big complaint about Godzilla films is usually the humans, but the human drama in this movie is so good that it's almost a shame when Godzilla shows up to do his thing. Almost.
goji-29.png
In the end, what's interesting is how the human drama crashes against Godzilla's massive toes. Because we can't completely divorce Godzilla's existence from our own, or from our choices.
sylvia10
sylvia11
In Minus One, Godzilla gives the disgraced war veterans of Japan a chance at a "do-over" that can protect their homeland instead of endangering it, and without needlessly sacrificing their lives. This does, however, present a drastically simplified version of Japan's role in WWII that never fully wrestles with its own wartime atrocities. As somebody who likes the film, this is a criticism of its themes I can agree with, but it's also certainly not a blind spot unique to this film. I'd feel pretty hypocritical as an American if I didn't at least mention that.
sylvia12
sylvia13
sylvia14
sylvia15
Yeah, I've certainly seen those kinds of criticisms leveled against this film, as well as the notion that it is ultimately a very nationalist film. I can certainly agree with the notion that the film doesn't do nearly enough to reconcile with Japan's own role in the war, but I do think that framing that as a form of nationalism is also being a bit dishonest. If anything, the film is extremely critical of the suicidal ideology that ran through the core of the Japanese military at the time, and wholeheartedly rejects it.
goji-33.png
goji-34.png
That also ties in pretty well with how Shikishima's arc concludes, as after spending the majority of the film hovering on the edge of death, he finds the strength to instead choose to live despite the uncertainty of the future.
goji-38.png
Yeah, the third act of the movie is immaculate, buoyed by Naoki Satō's ascendant soundtrack. Seriously, hearing this in a theater was spine-tingling.

Admittedly, on rewatch, I did have a brief guffaw at Shikishima seeing his little Dead Wife Vision (with the flowing white sheets and everything) right before slamming his plane into Godzilla's gaping maw (especially considering their reunion soon after). But aside from that hiccup, the action and drama of taking Godzilla down hit their marks.

sylvia16
sylvia17
No film is perfect, but it's not hard to see why this particular rendition of Godzilla hit so well with audiences. The story it tells feels incredibly human, and it ties back wonderfully to so many of the sentiments that helped to spawn Godzilla in the first place. It of course also helps that despite the film's relatively low budget, its version of Godzilla looks especially inspired.
goji-24.png
goji-39.png
Seriously, it's no wonder this film nabbed an Oscar for Visual Effects. The Godzilla in this movie looks so real you can practically feel the slime oozing off his scales.
Indeed! I'm eager to see how Minus Zero follows this act, now that it is laden with Minus One's accolades and expectations. Making a sequel to a surprise hit is never easy.
sylvia18
For my money, though, my favorite 21st-century iteration on the 'Zilla formula remains Shin Godzilla. And at least 80% of that favor is due to the existence of this little fella.
sylvia19
We'll have to see if Minus Zero can live up to the pedigree of its predecessor, but if there's one certain thing, it's that Godzilla can survive anything, so come what may, I'm sure he'll continue stomping around for decades to come.
And his stomping grounds aren't limited to the silver screen! Given Godzilla's Japanese origins, it's no surprise that he's graced the realm of anime more than once. I mean, if we want, we can even count Shin Godzilla as anime, since it's directed by Hideaki Anno and includes a bunch of visual and musical cues from Evangelion.
sylvia20
sylvia21
With how much every weeb I know has been singing its praises since it came out, I certainly wouldn't argue against it.
My weeb ass has watched it at least five times, including twice in theaters, and I will continue to do so. Meanwhile, I wouldn't blame people for forgetting these, but we also got a trio of Godzilla movies on Netflix from the twisted mind of Gen Urobuchi and the 3DCG wizards at Polygon Pictures. While I have not watched them myself, I'd encourage all of you to take a trip down memory lane and read these TWIA columns of yesteryear.
I have seen at least the first two, and they're about as brooding and pretentious as you'd expect from an Urobuchi joint, which made them a pretty good time from what I can remember, although I have heard less than stellar reactions towards the third film.
singular-point.png
"Pretentious" is also a word that some would probably use to describe Godzilla Singular Point, which mostly ignores a lot of the usual Godzilla stomping in favor of hard-core science fiction. They're wrong, though, because it absolutely rules.
The title does not lie, because it is absolutely one of the most singular takes on the franchise. Which is not at all surprising given the identity of its writer, Toh Enjoe. He's a gonzo sci-fi author whose book Self-Reference Engine remains one of the most unique reads I've ever done. He also penned the two weirdest Space Dandy episodes and recently worked on Science SARU's adaptation of The Ghost in the Shell. And I think it's really cool when a long-running franchise like this takes a chance on something experimental. Especially when the protagonist's character design is this good.
sylvia22
But before we close out, I think it's only appropriate to cast our glance backwards in time to where it all began. The original stomping grounds. Because if you've never seen the 1954 Godzilla, or if you haven't seen it recently, you ought to.
sylvia23
sylvia24
Godzilla has taken many forms, from a cool monster anti-hero to an unknowable divine force beyond mortal understanding, but at his core, he's a warning of the kind of destruction human hubris can bring about, and for as much has changed over the decades, I'm glad that there are still audiences who see something in that message.
Yeah, for over 70 years and counting, the original Godzilla has stood the test of time and changed the world. A guy in a rubber suit and a metaphor as blunt and satirical as the "Oxygen Destroyer" still hit hard today. We may be further temporally removed from the atrocities that gave birth to Godzilla, but we're no closer to properly reckoning with our own capacity for self-annihilation.
sylvia25
sylvia26
sylvia27
sylvia28
Until that day comes, we might as well band together with our mutual love for this ferocious fellow.
sylvia29
There are certainly worse ways to go than getting vaporized by atomic breath.
goji-32.png

discuss this in the forum (3 posts) |
bookmark/share with: short url

This Week in Anime homepage / archives